Embedded Files
All donations are tax-deductible.
Monthly Q&A #1: Law Enforcement and Your Rights
Monthly Q&A #1: Law Enforcement and Your Rights
This week marks our first Contextly Publish. I received a multitude of questions about police encounters, constitutional rights, and the protections people have when interacting with law enforcement. While every situation is different, understanding the basics can help you make informed decisions and better understand how the legal system works.
Can The Police Lie to You?
Can The Police Lie to You?
The short answer is yes. This surprises many people, but courts have generally allowed police officers to use certain deceptive tactics during investigations and interrogations. Officers may falsely claim that you're not in trouble, that they have evidence, that someone else already confessed, that they already know what happened, etc.
One of the most cited cases on this issue is Frazier v. Cupp, where the Supreme Court ruled that police falsely telling a suspect that another person had confessed did not automatically render the confession inadmissible.
However, this doesn't mean police can do anything they want. Courts still look at whether a confession was voluntary and whether officers crossed the line into coercion or threats.
Do You Have to Talk to The Police?
Do You Have to Talk to The Police?
Generally, no. The Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution protects people from being forced to incriminate themselves.
In Miranda v. Arizona, the Supreme Court ruled that people in police custody must be informed of their right to remain silent and their right to an attorney before questioning.
Many defense attorneys often say that talking rarely helps a suspect and can sometimes create misunderstandings or provide information that investigators did not previously have. This advice applies to both adults and minors.
What About Minors?
What About Minors?
Minors have constitutional rights, too.
In J.D.B. v. North Carolina, the Supreme Court ruled that a child's age should be considered when determining whether they are in custody for Miranda purposes.
Many states also have additional protections for juveniles during questioning. While laws vary, many legal experts recommend that minors ask for a parent, guardian, or attorney before answering questions related to a criminal investigation.
What Does "Am I Free to Go?" Mean?
What Does "Am I Free to Go?" Mean?
One submission highlighted a phrase that many attorneys encourage people to know: "Am I free to go?"
This simple question helps clearly determine whether you are participating in a voluntary encounter or whether police are detaining you.
The Supreme Court decision in Terry v. Ohio established that officers may briefly detain someone if they have reasonable suspicion that criminal activity is occurring. However, asking "Am I free to go?" does not automatically make future evidence inadmissible, despite some claims online. It simply helps clarify your legal status during the encounter.
Do Constitutional Rights Apply to Everyone?
Do Constitutional Rights Apply to Everyone?
A question was submitted asking whether rights apply only to citizens of the U.S. or to law-abiding individuals.
The short answer is no. Many constitutional protections apply to "persons" rather than only citizens. This includes due process protections under the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments.
Cases such as Yick Wo v. Hopkins and Plyler v. Doe helped establish that non-citizens physically present and/or residing in the United States are entitled to many constitutional protections.
However, this does not mean that immigration laws do not exist. It means that government actions must follow the same legal procedures and constitutional limits that it must with a United States Citizen.
Immigration Enforcement and Warrants
Immigration Enforcement and Warrants
Several questions focused on immigration enforcement and warrants.
If ICE officers come to a residence, one important thing is to understand that not all warrants are the same. A judicial warrant is signed by a judge and generally carries different authority than an Administrative Immigration warrant.
People can ask officers to identify themselves, and they can request to see any warrant being used. Whether officers can enter a home depends on the circumstances and the type of warrant involved.
A valid search warrant typically includes:
The location being searched
The Items being sought
the signature of a judge or magistrate
There is no national public database where individuals can instantly verify every warrant or every judge who may sign one. Questions about a warrant's validity are typically addressed through the courts.
Key Takeaways
Key Takeaways
Police can legally use some deceptive tactics during investigations.
You generally have the right to remain silent.
All minors have constitutional rights. Minors may have additional protections in some states.
Asking "Am I free to go?" is an important phrase and can help clarify whether you are being detained.
Constitutional protections apply to non-citizens physically present and/or residing on U.S. soil, not just U.S. citizens.
Understanding the difference between judicial and administrative warrants is important.
Works Cited
Works Cited
Congress.Gov. “Fourth Amendment.” Constitution.congress.gov, constitution.congress.gov/browse/amendment-4/.
Constitution Annotated. “Fourteenth Amendment.” Constitution.congress.gov, Library of Congress, constitution.congress.gov/browse/amendment-14/.
Cornell Law School. “Self-Incrimination.” LII / Legal Information Institute, 25 Jan. 2018, www.law.cornell.edu/wex/self-incrimination.
“Fifth Amendment | Browse | Constitution Annotated | Congress.gov | Library of Congress.” Constitution.congress.gov, constitution.congress.gov/browse/amendment-5/.
“Frazier v. Cupp.” Oyez, www.oyez.org/cases/1968/643.
“J.D.B. V. North Carolina.” Oyez, www.oyez.org/cases/2010/09-11121.
Juvenile Law Center. “Juvenile Law Center.” Juvenile Law Center, 12 Nov. 2019, jlc.org/.
“Know Your Rights in Texas: Preparing for State’s New Anti-Immigrant Law SB4.” American Immigration Council, 27 Mar. 2025, www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/blog/know-your-rights-sb4/.
Legal Information Institute. “Rule 41. Search and Seizure.” LII / Legal Information Institute, 30 Nov. 2016, www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcrmp/rule_41.
“Miranda v. Arizona.” Oyez, www.oyez.org/cases/1965/759.
“Plyler v. Doe.” Oyez, www.oyez.org/cases/1981/80-1538.
“Terry v Ohio.” Oyez, www.oyez.org/cases/1967/67.
“Yick Wo v. Hopkins.” Oyez, 2019, www.oyez.org/cases/1850-1900/118us356.
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse